IFRS 16CoreHealthcare & Pharma

Hospital building and equipment leases

IFRS 16 · Leases

Applies to: All business models

In plain words

Clinics and hospitals often lease their buildings and major equipment. The question is how to account for these leases. Under IFRS 16 the lessee recognises a right-of-use asset and a lease liability, using a lease term that includes renewals reasonably certain to be exercised, for example because of costly fit-out. Short-term and low-value leases can be exempt. Rent expense becomes depreciation plus interest, which changes EBITDA and leverage.

Why it matters

Because healthcare providers typically lease rather than own facilities and major equipment, correctly capitalizing right-of-use assets and lease liabilities materially changes total assets, total liabilities and EBITDA (rent expense is replaced by depreciation and interest), directly affecting leverage covenants, comparability between owned and leased operators, and reported operating performance.

Diagnostic questions

Does the contract convey the right to control a specific, identified premises or piece of equipment for a period, or is it in substance a service arrangement where the supplier can substitute the asset at will? What lease term applies once renewal options that are reasonably certain (e.g. supported by sunk leasehold improvements or lack of alternative sites) are included? Are maintenance or service components embedded in an equipment lease that must be separated from the lease component before measuring the right-of-use asset and liability?

Recognition

1) At contract inception, confirm the arrangement conveys the right to control an identified asset (specific premises, a specific scanner) for a period in exchange for consideration, distinguishing it from a pure service contract. 2) Determine the lease term including renewal options that are reasonably certain (e.g. supported by sunk leasehold improvement costs or lack of practical alternative sites). 3) Separate any embedded maintenance/service components in equipment leases from the lease component using observable standalone prices, unless the practical expedient to combine is elected for a class of underlying assets. 4) At commencement, recognize a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for all leases unless the short-term (≤12 months) or low-value asset exemptions apply. 5) Depreciate the right-of-use asset (generally straight-line over the lease term) and unwind the liability using the effective interest method. 6) Reassess and remeasure the lease term and liability when a renewal or termination option's likelihood changes, or when lease payments change with an index/rate.

Measurement

Measure the lease liability at the present value of unpaid lease payments (fixed payments, in-substance fixed payments, variable payments linked to an index/rate, reasonably certain renewal-period payments, and expected residual value guarantees/purchase options), discounted using the rate implicit in the lease if readily determinable, otherwise the lessee's incremental borrowing rate. Measure the right-of-use asset at the initial lease liability plus initial direct costs, prepayments and estimated restoration costs, less lease incentives received. Remeasure both when triggering events occur (rent reviews, reassessed term).

Presentation & disclosure

Present right-of-use assets and lease liabilities separately on the face of the statement of financial position or disclose them clearly in the notes; disclose a maturity analysis of lease liabilities; disclose expense for short-term and low-value leases not capitalized; disclose significant judgments on determining the lease term and the discount rate used; disclose the split of lease payments between principal and interest and their cash flow classification.

Common mistakes

  • Continuing to expense long-term facility leases as rent without capitalizing a right-of-use asset and lease liability
  • failing to separate embedded maintenance services in equipment leases from the lease component, overstating the lease liability
  • not reassessing the lease term when a renewal becomes reasonably certain due to sunk fit-out costs, understating the liability
  • using the wrong discount rate (e.g. the entity'
  • s general borrowing rate instead of one reflecting the lease term, currency and security)
  • presenting the entire lease payment as an operating cash outflow instead of splitting principal (financing) from interest.

Simple example

A clinic signs a 10-year lease for premises at SAR 900,000 per year with a reasonably certain 5-year renewal (15 years total) given significant leasehold improvements, discounted at an incremental borrowing rate of 6%, giving a lease liability/right-of-use asset of approximately SAR 8,741,000.
At commencement: Dr Right-of-use asset - premises 8,741,000 / Cr Lease liability 8,741,000.
Year 1: interest on the liability of SAR 524,460 (6% x 8,741,000) and a cash payment of SAR 900,000, of which SAR 375,540 reduces the liability principal: Dr Interest expense 524,460 / Dr Lease liability 375,540 / Cr Cash 900,000.
Year 1 depreciation of the right-of-use asset (straight-line over 15 years): Dr Depreciation expense 582,733 / Cr Accumulated depreciation - right-of-use asset 582,733.

Professional judgment

Judgment is needed in determining the incremental borrowing rate (rate implicit in the lease is rarely known for real-estate leases), assessing reasonably certain renewal options given sunk leasehold-improvement costs common in healthcare fit-outs, and separating lease from service components in bundled equipment/maintenance contracts where standalone prices are not directly observable. A further grey area is whether a service agreement (e.g. equipment placement tied to reagent purchases) contains an embedded lease at all, which requires assessing whether the supplier retains a substantive right of substitution.

Source basis

IFRS 16 · Leases

Paragraph references

IFRS 16.9IFRS 16.18IFRS 16.22IFRS 16.26

Verified against the official standard texts used in the IFRS Expert skill.

IFRS 16 Leases
Issued: 13 January 2016 · Effective: 1 January 2019

Related issues

Educational and navigation content only. Not professional advice. Does not reproduce official IFRS/IAS text. Consult the authoritative standards and qualified professionals; professional judgment may still be required.